The American Philosophical Society, founded by Benjamin Franklin in 1743, proudly bears the title of the nation's oldest learned society.  Our founders participated in the birth of American democracy. It pains us greatly that all these years later, our nation's promise has yet to be fulfilled.  We join all Americans of good will in deploring the senseless murder of George Floyd at the hands of the Minneapolis police. Over these past months the Society has hosted a number of virtual programs.  Even as we now resume our work with the offering of new programs, our attention remains focused on the senseless loss of innocent lives and our commitment to the difficult, necessary conversations and actions we must all take to begin to ensure that such tragedies end. Read more about virtual programming and resources that can be accessed remotely. Read more about the APS response to COVID-19.

Studies in the Human Voice

Marian L. Christ is Assistant Librarian and Head Cataloger/Bibliographer. She received her MLS from Drexel University and BA from Beaver...

Emma Seiler (1821-1886), the fifth woman elected to membership in the American Philosophical Society (1870), was born in Würzburg, Bavaria and came to Philadelphia in the late 1860s. A student and teacher of voice and elocution, she opened a school and gave lessons to advanced students in music.

voice in singing
Emma Seiler, The Voice in Singing (Phiadelphia: J.B. Lippincott & Co., 1868), APS Collections.

While still in Europe, Madam Seiler consulted many eminent vocal coaches about her own singing and how best to instruct students in the discipline, but she became frustrated because no two of them agreed on teaching methods. She also, during this period of studying voice, lost her own; and although it was temporary, she believed it to be the result of poor teaching techniques and became convinced that she should begin her career as a teacher of voice with scientific investigation. She acknowledged the importance of the art of singing, but pointed out: “Thus is there not only an aesthetical side to the art of singing, but a physiological and a physical side also, without an exact knowledge, appreciation, observance, and study of which,  what is hurtful cannot be discerned and avoided, and no true culture of art, and consequently no progress in singing, is possible.” This conviction led her to Herman von Helmholtz, the 19th-century German physicist and physician, then conducting research into the basis of musical sounds. She participated in his investigations on the physiology of the voice, and observed with the laryngoscope the reaction in the larynx during the production of different tones. Her work, The Voice in Singing (784.9 Se4v), described her discovery, achieved through the observations made with the laryngoscope, that the sudden contraction of the vocal ligaments produced different tones. 

This laryngoscope in the APS Museum's Collections belonged to Emma Seiler. Convinced that vocal injuries were caused by faulty advice from physicians who had not studied living throats, Seiler used her laryngoscope to research the natural position of the lips, tongue, and glottis (vocal folds) during singing. Her observations revealed that the sudden contraction of the vocal ligaments produced different tones.

She came to America in 1866, armed with testimonials from von Helmholtz and Professor du Bois Reymond, Chair of Physiology in the Royal University of Berlin. When she ultimately settled in Philadelphia and established her school for the study of voice, she not only gave lessons to students of music, but found her vocal instruction in demand by actors, clergyman, and others suffering from the misuse of their voices. Her own experiences with poor vocal instruction led her to dedicate her career to finding the best techniques to promote vocal health.


Harford Flemming, A sketch of the life of Madam Seiler (Philadelphia: William H. Hoskins, 1887?).

Emma Seiler, The Voice in Singing (Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott & Co., 1868).

More from the blog

American Philosophical Society
American Philosophical Society